Holiday blend · Medium roast
Frosty's Favorite® Holiday Flavored Coffee
Cinnamon graham on a creamy, nutty background that even a snowman can't resist. This smooth medium roast is made for cold winter nights, folded into 100% Arabica beans and roasted in small batches to share with the people you love.
- Cinnamon graham
- Creamy & nutty
- Smooth medium roast
- 100% Arabica
100% Arabica
Roasted in small batches
Family-run since 2003
Can't pick just one?
Try our top three holiday best sellers in one box, $24.99
Sugar free
No artificial sweeteners
Keto friendly
Allergen free
Mold free
Tasting notes
A snow day in every cup
Frosty's Favorite opens with warm cinnamon graham, then melts into a creamy, nutty finish over a smooth, mellow medium roast that never turns bitter. It tastes like coming in from the snow to a warm kitchen: sweet, cozy and a little playful.
- Roast
- Medium
- Origin
- Central America
- Bean
- 100% Arabica
- Flavor
- Cinnamon graham · Creamy nut
- Caffeine
- Regular or decaf
Main Street Roasters®
Small-town roasters. Big holiday flavor.
We've roasted in small batches since 2003, never in giant warehouse runs. Every bag gets the same care we'd give a cup we were pouring for family, and we roast to order, so your coffee arrives with a roast date just days old.
Roasted in small batches
Small runs mean every batch is air roasted with precision using our tried and true method.
Only Arabica beans
A smooth, naturally sweet base that lets the cinnamon graham shine, with the roast date printed on every bag.
Family-run since 2003
Hometown hospitality has guided us since we first opened our doors, and we bring it to every online order.
Brew guide
Brew your merriest cup
-
1
Measure
Use about 2 tablespoons of coffee for every 6 oz of water. Want more cinnamon graham? Add a little extra.
-
2
Grind fresh
Went with whole bean? Grind medium for drip and pour-over, and coarse for French press, right before you brew.
-
3
Brew & enjoy
Water just off the boil (195–205°F) brings out the cinnamon graham. Great black, even cozier with a splash of cream on a snowy morning.
Why brew at home
Better mornings. Fresh coffee. Delivered.
Save on your daily cup. Brewing at home makes holiday coffee an affordable everyday treat.
Skip the extra stop. Enjoy your first cup in your favorite mug without another errand.
Look forward to mornings. Cinnamon graham flavor makes the routine feel like a celebration.
Make it your way. Hot or iced, strong or mellow, with your favorite creamer.
Fill the house with holiday aroma. Few things welcome guests like a fresh cinnamon graham pot brewing.
Keep your favorites close. Coffee delivered to your door means one less thing on your list.
Enjoy a moment before the rush. A quiet cup before the gift wrapping starts.
Support a family roastery. Freshly roasted by our family in small-town Indiana.
Holiday gifting
A gift that's opened every morning
Stocking stuffer
The 10 oz bag fits right in a stocking. An easy, cozy gift for neighbors, teachers and coworkers, from $12.99.
Choose a sizeStock up for the season
Hosting the family or fueling the office? Grab the 5 lb bag and keep the Frosty's pot brewing all season long.
Shop the 5 lb bagHoliday sample pack
Can't pick just one? Our top three holiday best sellers in one box for $24.99. Perfect for sharing.
Shop the sample packQuestions, answered
What does Frosty's Favorite taste like?
Warm cinnamon graham on a creamy, nutty background over a smooth medium roast. Sweet and comforting, with a mellow finish that never turns bitter.
Does it contain sugar?
No. Our flavored coffees are sugar free with no artificial sweeteners, so you get all the cinnamon graham flavor without the sugar. Sweeten it however you like.
Is there a decaf version?
Yes. Choose "Decaf" under Caffeine for the same cinnamon graham flavor without the buzz, ideal for an after-dinner holiday cup.
Whole bean or ground: which should I choose?
Whole bean stays fresh longest if you have a grinder. Ground is ready for drip coffee makers and pour-over right out of the bag.
How fresh will my coffee be?
We roast to order, so your bag arrives with a roast date within days of your order, depending on transit time.
How should I store my coffee?
Keep it sealed in its bag or an airtight container, somewhere cool, dark and dry. Skip the fridge, since moisture dulls the flavor.
Warm hearts on the coldest nights.
Cinnamon graham and creamy, nutty notes for every snowy morning and holiday gathering. Roasted in small batches, with bags from $12.99.

